What a Country Owes Its Soldiers by Saira Mohamed (Belknap, 2026).
Reviewed by Elizabeth Stice
In 1967, Pete Seeger’s song “Waist Deep in the Big Muddy” caused a stir about censorship on television. The song was about a platoon wading through a river during training in 1942, led by a foolish captain. In the first stanza, “We were -- knee deep in the Big Muddy,/ But the big fool said to push on.” In the next they were “waist deep,” but the captain “said to push on.” In the early stanzas, the sergeant asks about turning back. In one he points out that the men won’t be able to swim with all their equipment—in that stanza they push on even though they’re neck deep. Finally, the captain drowns and the sergeant takes over. Seeger continues
Well, I'm not going to point any moral,
I'll leave that for yourself
Maybe you're still walking, you're still talking
You'd like to keep your health.
But every time I read the papers
That old feeling comes on;
We're, waist deep in the Big Muddy
And the big fool says to push on.
In 1967, Seeger performed this song on The Smothers Brothers, but it didn’t run with the rest of the recording on television. It was censored by CBS, which considered it too political and anti-war.
Seeger’s song resembled a real training incident in 1956, in which a sergeant led Marines into Ribbon Creek and cost six of them their lives. Saira Mohamed’s book, What a Country Owes Its Soldiers, opens with more recent training incidents. Most were not caused by foolish individuals, but by patterns of neglect, deficient equipment, and insufficient training. Mohamed also identifies wartime incidents in which the harm was caused by inadequate protection or inappropriate orders. Who is responsible in situations like that? What happens when “the big fool” is wrong? What a Country Owes Its Soldiers explores the lack of legal protection for soldiers’ rights and how that reflects the ways we think about soldiers.
Mohamed has set an ambitious goal for this book, “to change the way a reader thinks about the relationship between the state and the soldier” (6). She will succeed with many readers. What a Country Owes Its Soldiers is not an anti-war or anti-military screed or an attack on the civilian realm. The shift in thinking Mohamed hopes to provoke can probably be summed up well by one sentence in the introduction: “Accepting the possibility of death in service of one’s country must not be mistaken for accepting any and all kinds of mistreatment” (10).
The two parts of What a Country are named after lines from Wilfred Owen’s World War I poem “Anthem for Doomed Youth.” The first part, “What Passing-Bells For These Who Die As Cattle?” explores the harms that soldiers endure from their own side—physical and mental—and the ways in which those harms and the soldiers who experience them are often invisible to the law. Mohamed looks at the Uniform Code of Military Justice, U.S. domestic law, Supreme Court cases, and international human rights law. Even most human rights law sees soldiers almost exclusively as perpetrators of violence and most courts do not consider harm soldiers receive from their own side as potentially criminal, much less as possible war crimes. Mohamed’s contention is that what happens to soldiers is sometimes criminal and that it is possible for soldiers to be victims, in part because they are still people, not just extensions of the state.
Part two is titled “What Candles May Be Held To Speed Them All?” These chapters of the book explore perceptions and narratives about the U.S. military and its soldiers. As others have pointed out, as military service becomes less common and more familial, those without connections to the military often know very little about it. Most Americans are running on impressions rather than knowledge when it comes to the military. Paradoxically, the celebration of soldiers in airports and at sporting events and the claims about their moral excellence have obscured their humanity and, in some ways, made it harder to seriously consider how we treat them.
Throughout the book Mohamed calls our attention back to the humanity of soldiers. We may have a volunteer army and soldiers may agree to undertake risks, but, “The soldier is not merely an extension of the state; the soldier is a person, with inherent dignity, just like the civilian, and therefore when the government exercises jurisdiction over the soldier, it has human rights obligations with respect to that soldier” (173). One of her chapters is titled “Soldiers’ Rights are Human Rights.” She also looks to international human rights law—though not exclusively—for ways that it “provides an architecture for how to understand the obligations of government to its soldiers” (173).
What a Country Owes Its Soldiers is readable, well-researched, and relevant. Mohamed integrates training incidents and questionable orders from the last twenty-five years, as well as legal precedents and military policies from the previous century. The writing is clear-sighted and compassionate without being sentimental. The soldiers in these pages are neither all victims nor all horrible perpetrators—they are human beings entitled to some protection from their state. For example, the goal of her second chapter is to get the reader to concede that “perpetrators of abuse and powerful people and heroes all can be rights holders, and that political and military leaders alike owe subordinates a duty of protection” (57). The question is not whether or not soldiers should be exposed to harm, but whether or not they should be protected from abuse.
This book may have readers asking certain questions for the first time. Why should soldiers be expected to shoulder the burdens caused by negligence in cases of inadequate protection and training? Why aren’t soldiers considered the victims of criminal orders when they receive them? Should soldiers be able to conscientiously object to particular wars that violate their conscience, or may be illegal? Why can’t soldiers be the victims of war crimes if the perpetrators are on their own side? Why does any suggestion that soldiers’ lives have been “wasted” get translated as a criticism of the soldiers rather than the system? Mohamed navigates these topics without being overly liberal or conservative. And while she offers some suggestions, she does not offer up a dramatic model for legal reform or any recommendations about lawsuits. She is not out to “get” anybody. She is out to render the invisible visible.
What a Country Owes Its Soldiers is a refreshing book. It takes on a timely and potentially very charged issue in a way that is helpful and direct. Some of the book’s endorsers suggest that it will change the way you think about things. It very well might. As Mohamed recounts, “When I explain to fellow scholars the focus of my research on the obligations a government owes its soldiers, I hear again and again the same response: ‘I never thought of that before’” (53).
Wilfred Owen’s “Anthem for Doomed Youth” anchors the two sections of this book and it is a logical choice. The Great War has come to represent wasted youth and its soldiers are often seen as “lions led by donkeys.” Yet the Great War was a turning point in how soldiers were viewed. The massive citizen armies and the justice of the wartime cause (at the time) convinced the public that soldiers were typically heroic and special, rather than simply residents at the bottom of the social ladder. In previous wars, many soldiers were buried in mass graves, but after the Great War, men were buried individually—each with their own headstone, even the unknown. Men were more than cannon fodder, even if they were sometimes spent that way. What a Country Owes Its Soldiers suggests that another shift is possible, one in which we not only recognize the value of individual soldiers but the humanity of all soldiers, in a way which will uphold their rights as humans.
Elizabeth Stice is a professor of history and assistant director of the honors program at Palm Beach Atlantic University. She is the author of Empire Between the Lines: Imperial Culture in British and French Trench Newspapers of the Great War (2023) and she is a contributing editor and associate books editor at Front Porch Republic. Her next book is The Art of Living and it’s coming out soon.